Architizer Home
Architizer Homepage Projects People Firms Products A+ Awards
LOGIN    REGISTER

Log into Architizer

cancel
 
Login
Forgot your password? Register
News Jobs Competitions
back

Architizer News

No Bauhaus in Ebert’s House?

July 15, 2010


ThumbsdownmiesRoger Ebert isn’t afraid to admit he likes lighter films Get Him to the Greek and Iron Man 2 (three stars) but is also smart enough to enjoy higher-brow fare like The White Ribbon and I Am Love (four stars). Maybe that’s why he’s trusted as America’s foremost film critic—he sees quality wherever it is, often resisting conventional wisdom. He even loved Air Bud, the tale of a basketball-playing dog — so democratic!

As seen in his review of Air Bud, Ebert may be a fan of tugged heartstrings: “The climactic scenes are not only absurd and goofy but also enormously entertaining.” Ebert says, “By the end of the film I was quietly amazed: not only could Buddy play basketball, but I actually cared how the game turned out.”

Many design fans wonder aloud, who will be the Roger Ebert of architecture, combining populism and artistic knowledge with just a smidgen of emotion. How about, say. . . Roger Ebert!

In a rant published online, Ebert proclaims his dual populist/intelligentsia views on this new subject in a convincing piece whose title is based on a Louis Sullivan quote, “Every building is the image…” Sullivan is a seminal figure in Chicago architectural history, and likewise revered by Ebert as the inspiration to Frank Lloyd Wright’s Prairie School of Architecture and the Arts and Crafts movement.

Ebert doesn’t revere Sullivan as much for his ability to find a new vocabulary for the skyscrapers, but for his ornamentation; as Sullivan once said, “a building’s identity resides in its ornament.” Turns out Ebert is a softie when it comes to architecture in his Chicago.  Sullivan’s buildings, such as the Wainwright Tower in St. Louis, was amazing for its cornices, decorations and entrances—but Sullivan was a transitional figure to Mies van der Rohe’s “deliberate simplicity.”

Wainwright

Wainwright Building (Thumbs up!), St. Louis Photo by Matthew Black

CrownHall

Crown Hall, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago (Thumbs down!) via Art Net

Mies van der Rohe is Ebert’s foremost target: “He and his generation seem to have pointed us down the road to an architecture that is totalitarian in its severe economy.” It’s hard to refute that; in spite of whatever beauty Mies found in his proportions, the Farnsworth House, or Crown Hall on the Campus of IIT, he may also have lead the way to the mediocre glass towers we find in downtowns throughout the U.S. So why didn’t we stick with the Hogwart’s charm of Ebert’s ideal, the gothic University of Chicago?

Like Tom Wolfe’s entertaining From Bauhaus to Our House , Ebert has oversimplified modern architecture to a point in architectural history that was soon refuted by its own members. Even Le Corbusier moved on from the Villa Savoye to Ronchamp, a curving, mysterious shape that is immune to description. True, the damage was already done, but the rise of industry and population demanded cheap solutions fast, which had little to do with Mies’ Crown Hall.

But even if you give Ebert his anti-Mies point, on the same IIT Campus in Chicago is an example of more promising modern architecture built recently: the McCormick-Tribune Campus Center designed by the Office of Metropolitan Architecture headed by Rem Koolhaas. This is a glass and steel building, but filled with electrifying experiential cues: orange walls, bold and funny graphic design, a strange tunnel above that wraps the L tracks, interior gardens, sculptural stairways, and above all jagged forms that come from its location in the middle of campus. It does not have stone carvings. But it does warm this heart.

IIT

McCormick-Tribune Campus Center, Chicago

But if that doesn’t do it for you, there are still other examples of humanistic modern architecture — even in Chicago — created after Mies (Ebert should feel free to visit these and judge for himself). Looking through the Architizer database yields a few Chicago winners:

Brick Weave

Brick Weave House, Chicago

Studio Gang’s Brick Weave House uses a porous screen to dapple sunlight. At night the house becomes a lantern. Its ornamentation is better than stone: light.

StateStreet

State Street Village, Chicago

Yet another example of heart-warming modern architecture on the IIT Campus, State Street Village by Murphy/Jahn uses large curving metal screens as both ornament and shield. The building is one of a kind, with its own unique identity.

Many people agree with Ebert’s love of gothic ornamentation: campuses are continuously being added to, not with modern architects, but Gothic facades. “Collegate Gothic Style” feels about as empty to me as Mies does to Ebert. At least Mies was being truthful to his time, as were his less than perfect followers.


user image

by Jim Wegener

posted in General

tagged Air Bud, criticism, IIT, Louis Sullivan, mies van der rohe, oma, roger ebert

more articles by Jim Wegener


previous

Space Oddity

next

Friday Brew

previous next
Architizer News
  • Summer Video Game Series

    We kick off our new series with Prison Architect
  • A Showroom That Feels Like Home

    LuxeHome’s GE Monogram Design Center is anything but ordinary
  • IE School Of Architecture's New Program

    Designers learn to identify work opportunities
  • Building Taken Apart And Put Back Together

    See ‘Evolucio’ by Onionlab reassemble this building!
  • New James Turrell Exhibit At Guggenheim

    3 simulataneous Turrel retrospectives to open June 21st

Search

search
  • A+
  • Competition
  • Debate
  • editor's pick
  • exhibitions
  • first look
  • Heritage
  • Money Shot
  • New Projects
  • news
  • Product
  • sustainable design
  • top ten
Follow Us:
 

A+ Awards: Latest News

  • “This Is Blowing My Mind!”: ..., more May 21 2013
  • A Roundup Of Architizer A+ Relevance Awa..., more May 20 2013
  • Robert Hammond And Joshua David Win Arch..., more May 20 2013
  • Go Brooklyn: SHoP Architects’ Barc..., more May 17 2013
  • Richard Meier: Architizer Lifetime Achie..., more May 17 2013
Featured Projects
105 Villiers
105 Villiers
Shaun Lockyer Architects
Fletiomare Utrecht
Fletiomare Utrecht
Slangen + Koenis Architecte..
Haus Walde
Haus Walde
Gogl Architekten
Gros Ventre Residence
Gros Ventre Residence
Stephen Dynia Architects
Great Fen Visitor  Centre
Great Fen Visitor Cent..
Shiro Studio
House J
House J
Keiko Maita Architect Offic..

Blogroll

  • A Daily Dose of Architecture
  • abitare
  • ARCH’IT
  • ArchDaily
  • ArchiExpo
  • Archinect
  • Architect Magazine
  • Architect’s Newspaper
  • Architectural Record
  • ARTCO LLC Blog
  • Azure
  • Baumeister
  • BLDGBLOG
  • Blueprint Magazine
  • Building Design
  • Cool Hunting
  • Coolboom
  • Curbed
  • Death By Architecture
  • Design + Build
  • Design Observer
  • Detail
  • DWELL
  • Flavorwire
  • Freshome
  • Guardian Architecture
  • Hochparterre
  • I.D. Magazine
  • Inhabitat
  • KOLLECTIF.NET
  • Metropolis Magazine
  • NY Times – Arts & Design
  • Remodelista
  • Repeat. No Repeat.
  • Surface Magazine
  • Talkitect
  • Trend Hunter
  • Urbanverse
  • Wallpaper
Advertise|FAQ|About Architizer|Privacy Policy|Terms of Use|Contact|Invite
Copyright © 2009 Architizer LLC. All rights reserved. Copyright Policy